Proposal for the Application of a Quality Indicator to Medico-legal Consultations in the Field of Medical Liability

Title:Proposal for the Application of a Quality Indicator to Medico-legal Consultations in the Field of Medical Liability

Volume: 22 Issue: 15

Author(s): Matteo Bolcato, Matteo Sanavio*, Daniele Rodriguez and Anna Aprile

Affiliation:

• Department of Cardiac, Thoracic, Vascular Sciences and Public Health, Legal Medicine, University of Padua,Italy

Keywords: Medical liability, legal medicine, medico-legal evaluation, clinical risk management, guidelines, quality indicator.

Abstract:

Introduction: In recent decades, the number of professional liability disputes has increased, especially in the civil sector. In these liability assessments, medico-legal experts have become the linchpin. Law No. 24/2017, concerning professional liability in Italy, requires that guidelines and best practices be established to identify the necessary elements for writing expert reports in the legal sector.

Materials and Methods: The authors have created a numerical indicator to be applied to 150 legal expert reports on professional liability, enabling them to evaluate the methodological quality of those reports. The results are then compared with the outcome of the legal proceedings in order to establish the suitability of this quality index for evaluating the work of medico-legal experts.

Results: Of the 150 reports considered, 14 were scored inadequate, 75 adequate and 31 good. These inadequate (according to the indicator) reports presented a higher probability of being scored inadequate in court proceedings, compared to the risk of inadequacy of all the reports; OR 4.6 (95% CI 1.25-16.90). This probability significantly increased on comparing the inadequate reports with the adequate; OR 5.6 (95% CI 1.28-24.41), and the inadequate with the good; OR 7.73 (95% CI 1.50- 39.87).

Discussion: Application of the proposed indicator is simple and produces a high-quality result, thus ensuring an accurate and tenable appraisal of methodological quality.

Conclusion: The indicator proposed serves as a useful starting point for creating the necessary methodological standards for medico-legal experts in the field of professional liability as recommended by Law No. 24/2017.

Cite this article as:

Bolcato Matteo , Sanavio Matteo *, Rodriguez Daniele and Aprile Anna , Proposal for the Application of a Quality Indicator to Medico-legal Consultations in the Field of Medical Liability, Current Pharmaceutical Biotechnology 2021; 22 (15) . https://dx.doi.org/10.2174/1389201021666201211104611