Abstract
We carried out a systematic review of HPV vaccine pre- and post-licensure trials to assess the evidence of their effectiveness and safety. We find that HPV vaccine clinical trials design, and data interpretation of both efficacy and safety outcomes, were largely inadequate. Additionally, we note evidence of selective reporting of results from clinical trials (i.e., exclusion of vaccine efficacy figures related to study subgroups in which efficacy might be lower or even negative from peer-reviewed publications). Given this, the widespread optimism regarding HPV vaccines long-term benefits appears to rest on a number of unproven assumptions (or such which are at odd with factual evidence) and significant misinterpretation of available data. For example, the claim that HPV vaccination will result in approximately 70% reduction of cervical cancers is made despite the fact that the clinical trials data have not demonstrated to date that the vaccines have actually prevented a single case of cervical cancer (let alone cervical cancer death), nor that the current overly optimistic surrogate marker-based extrapolations are justified. Likewise, the notion that HPV vaccines have an impressive safety profile is only supported by highly flawed design of safety trials and is contrary to accumulating evidence from vaccine safety surveillance databases and case reports which continue to link HPV vaccination to serious adverse outcomes (including death and permanent disabilities). We thus conclude that further reduction of cervical cancers might be best achieved by optimizing cervical screening (which carries no such risks) and targeting other factors of the disease rather than by the reliance on vaccines with questionable efficacy and safety profiles.
Keywords: HPV vaccines, Gardasil, Cervarix, adverse reactions, vaccine efficacy, vaccine safety, conflict of interests, clinical trials, cervical cancers, safety profile
Current Pharmaceutical Design
Title:Human Papillomavirus (HPV) Vaccines as an Option for Preventing Cervical Malignancies: (How) Effective and Safe?
Volume: 19 Issue: 8
Author(s): Lucija Tomljenovic, Jean Pierre Spinosa and Christopher A. Shaw
Affiliation:
Keywords: HPV vaccines, Gardasil, Cervarix, adverse reactions, vaccine efficacy, vaccine safety, conflict of interests, clinical trials, cervical cancers, safety profile
Abstract: We carried out a systematic review of HPV vaccine pre- and post-licensure trials to assess the evidence of their effectiveness and safety. We find that HPV vaccine clinical trials design, and data interpretation of both efficacy and safety outcomes, were largely inadequate. Additionally, we note evidence of selective reporting of results from clinical trials (i.e., exclusion of vaccine efficacy figures related to study subgroups in which efficacy might be lower or even negative from peer-reviewed publications). Given this, the widespread optimism regarding HPV vaccines long-term benefits appears to rest on a number of unproven assumptions (or such which are at odd with factual evidence) and significant misinterpretation of available data. For example, the claim that HPV vaccination will result in approximately 70% reduction of cervical cancers is made despite the fact that the clinical trials data have not demonstrated to date that the vaccines have actually prevented a single case of cervical cancer (let alone cervical cancer death), nor that the current overly optimistic surrogate marker-based extrapolations are justified. Likewise, the notion that HPV vaccines have an impressive safety profile is only supported by highly flawed design of safety trials and is contrary to accumulating evidence from vaccine safety surveillance databases and case reports which continue to link HPV vaccination to serious adverse outcomes (including death and permanent disabilities). We thus conclude that further reduction of cervical cancers might be best achieved by optimizing cervical screening (which carries no such risks) and targeting other factors of the disease rather than by the reliance on vaccines with questionable efficacy and safety profiles.
Export Options
About this article
Cite this article as:
Tomljenovic Lucija, Pierre Spinosa Jean and A. Shaw Christopher, Human Papillomavirus (HPV) Vaccines as an Option for Preventing Cervical Malignancies: (How) Effective and Safe?, Current Pharmaceutical Design 2013; 19 (8) . https://dx.doi.org/10.2174/1381612811319080014
DOI https://dx.doi.org/10.2174/1381612811319080014 |
Print ISSN 1381-6128 |
Publisher Name Bentham Science Publisher |
Online ISSN 1873-4286 |
Call for Papers in Thematic Issues
"Tuberculosis Prevention, Diagnosis and Drug Discovery"
The Nobel Prize-winning discoveries of Mycobacterium tuberculosis and streptomycin have enabled an appropriate diagnosis and an effective treatment of tuberculosis (TB). Since then, many newer diagnosis methods and drugs have been saving millions of lives. Despite advances in the past, TB is still a leading cause of infectious disease mortality ...read more
Current Pharmaceutical challenges in the treatment and diagnosis of neurological dysfunctions
Neurological dysfunctions (MND, ALS, MS, PD, AD, HD, ALS, Autism, OCD etc..) present significant challenges in both diagnosis and treatment, often necessitating innovative approaches and therapeutic interventions. This thematic issue aims to explore the current pharmaceutical landscape surrounding neurological disorders, shedding light on the challenges faced by researchers, clinicians, and ...read more
Emerging and re-emerging diseases
Faced with a possible endemic situation of COVID-19, the world has experienced two important phenomena, the emergence of new infectious diseases and/or the resurgence of previously eradicated infectious diseases. Furthermore, the geographic distribution of such diseases has also undergone changes. This context, in turn, may have a strong relationship with ...read more
Melanoma and Non-Melanoma Skin Cancer Treatment: Standard of Care and Recent Advances
In this thematic issue, we aim to provide a standard of care of the diagnosis and treatment of melanoma and non-melanoma skin cancer. The editor will invite authors from different countries who will write review articles of melanoma and non-melanoma skin cancers. The Diagnosis, Staging, Surgical Treatment, Non-Surgical Treatment all ...read more
- Author Guidelines
- Graphical Abstracts
- Fabricating and Stating False Information
- Research Misconduct
- Post Publication Discussions and Corrections
- Publishing Ethics and Rectitude
- Increase Visibility of Your Article
- Archiving Policies
- Peer Review Workflow
- Order Your Article Before Print
- Promote Your Article
- Manuscript Transfer Facility
- Editorial Policies
- Allegations from Whistleblowers
- Announcements
Related Articles
-
A Pan-Cancer Review of <i>ALK</i> Mutations: Implications for Carcinogenesis and Therapy
Current Cancer Drug Targets Curcumin: Structure-Activity Relationship Towards its Role as a Versatile Multi-Targeted Therapeutics
Mini-Reviews in Organic Chemistry Matrix Metalloproteinases as Valid Clinical Target
Current Pharmaceutical Design Safe and Effective Kinase Inhibitors for the Treatment of Gynecological Cancers: In Silico Approach
Current Drug Metabolism Amaranth: A Pseudo-Cereal with Nutraceutical Properties
Current Nutrition & Food Science MiRNAs in Human Cancers: The Diagnostic and Therapeutic Implications
Current Pharmaceutical Design Cytotoxicity and Chemotherapeutic Potential of Natural Rosin Abietane Diterpenoids and their Synthetic Derivatives
Current Pharmaceutical Design Modification Strategies of Lipid-Based Nanocarriers for Mucosal Drug Delivery
Current Pharmaceutical Design Disorders of Sex Development: A Review
Current Women`s Health Reviews Anti-Proliferative, Anti-Inflammatory, Anti-Ulcerogenic and Wound Healing Properties of Chitosan
Current Bioactive Compounds Chitosan and Quercetin: Potential Hand in Hand Encountering Tumors in Oral Delivery System
Current Pharmaceutical Design miRNA-497 Enhances the Sensitivity of Colorectal Cancer Cells to Neoadjuvant Chemotherapeutic Drug
Current Protein & Peptide Science Cystic Hygroma with Multiple Benign Bone Lymphangiomas in an Adult Patient: A Rare Entity in the Differential Diagnosis of Multiple Osseous Lesions in Oncology Practice
Current Medical Imaging Trypsin-Chymotrypsin Inhibitors from Vigna mungo Seeds
Protein & Peptide Letters Recent Advances of Natural and Synthetic β-Carbolines as Anticancer Agents
Anti-Cancer Agents in Medicinal Chemistry Survivin Modulators: An Updated Patent Review (2011 - 2015)
Recent Patents on Anti-Cancer Drug Discovery Lipid-Protamine-DNA-Mediated Antigen Delivery
Current Drug Delivery Opportunities and Challenges for Host-Directed Therapies in Tuberculosis
Current Pharmaceutical Design A Review on Medical Image Registration as an Optimization Problem
Current Medical Imaging In-Vivo Gene Delivery by Sonoporation: Recent Progress and Prospects
Current Gene Therapy